1
$\begingroup$

I've been presented with this problem:

Say that Jupiter, with its diameter of 142,000 km, was located where Mars now orbits. What would be the angular size of (the newly-relocated) Jupiter during a close approach, when its distance would be 79,300,000 km? Would we be able to see Jupiter as a round object with our unaided eye, or only as a point of light?

The angular size is easy enough to calculate given $ \frac{Angular \space Size}{206,000} = \frac{Linear \space Size}{Distance} $.
So $\frac{Angular \space Size}{206,000} = \frac{142000}{79300000}$ meaning Angular Size = 369 seconds of arc.

However, would the unaided eye be able to see this? Knowing that the eye can detect 1 minute of arc across, surely it can detect 6.15? Any help appreciated, thanks!

$\endgroup$
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ One way to look at it is, moon is about 30, so about 1/5 the diameter of the moon. Yes, certainly visible as a "round" object. $\endgroup$ – Jeff Y Jan 26 '16 at 20:12
1
$\begingroup$

Yes, you could definitely see Jupiter as a round object if it's angular diameter was 369 arcseconds. The limit for seeing something as round appears to be a diameter of around 1 arcminute. Notes:

The M16 complex is visible to the naked eye on clear nights as a hazy patch

(and thus not a single point), and http://messier.seds.org/m/m016.html notes that M16 has an angular diameter of about 7 arcminutes.

In the real world, folks with excellent eyesight can resolve down to about 2 arcminutes. Folks with average eyesight can resolve about 3 arcminutes.

Of course, resolving a double star as two separate points of light isn't the same as seeing something as a circle, but provides a good upper limit.

The extreme crescent phase of Venus can be seen without a telescope by those with exceptionally acute eyesight, at the limit of human perception. The angular resolution of the naked eye is about 1 minute of arc. The apparent disk of Venus' extreme crescent measures between 60.2 and 66 seconds of arc,[4] depending on the distance from Earth. Nevertheless it is possible for observers with extremely acute eyesight to see a crescent Venus under ideal atmospheric circumstances.

Note also that Venus appears circle-like (not point-like) when it transits the Sun, but the same is true of Mercury, so this may be a special situation that doesn't count.

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.