According to this answer transits of Earth across the disk of the Sun as seen from Mars:

The (Arthur C.) Clarke story is quite correct. Earth (and Moon) would transit the sun from the viewpoint of Mars on 8 May 1905, 11 May 1984 and again on 10 Nov 2084.

no surprises there, but they

...follow a pattern of occurring after 26, 79 then 100 years.

Why is that exactly? Why this pattern?


Such transit events occur when Earth and Mars are simultaneously at a node where their orbital planes intersect.

Between transits at the same node, both Earth and Mars must complete whole numbers of orbits, where 1 Mars year = 1.8808 Earth years. Meeus and Goffin 1983 identify patterns of 79-year and 284-year intervals:

79.0 Earth years ≈ 42.0 Mars years
284.0 Earth years ≈ 151.0 Mars years

Their Table II arranges the May and November transit dates in separate "panoramas" with 284 years between rows and 79 years between columns. These are somewhat analogous to a saros-inex panorama of solar eclipses.

Between transits at opposite nodes, both Earth and Mars must complete odd numbers of half-orbits:

Nov→May: 25.5 Earth years ≈ 13.56 Mars years
May→Nov: 100.5 Earth years ≈ 53.43 Mars years

These Mars year fractions differ from 0.5 because the half-orbit near perihelion takes significantly less time than the half near aphelion. Meeus and Goffin Table I also shows some intervals of 21.5 and 53.5 years outside the present few centuries.

  • $\begingroup$ Very nice answer, thanks! $\endgroup$
    – uhoh
    Aug 11 '19 at 22:54

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.