2
$\begingroup$

We know Halley's Comet returns every 75-76 years. We can reasonably compute its elliptical orbit.

We know that the Oort Cloud is a cloud of predominantly icy planetesimals proposed to surround the Sun at distances ranging from 2,000 to 200,000 au. We divide it into two regions: a disc-shaped inner Oort cloud (or Hills cloud) and a spherical outer Oort cloud.

We know that some comets are thought to have originated from the Oort cloud.

My question is: Does Halley's Comet travel past the outer bounds of the Oort Cloud?

Improve this question
$\endgroup$
2
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ "We know that the Oort Cloud ..." We don't "know" anything about the Oort Cloud, it's still yet to be observed and is a hypothetical region. $\endgroup$ – curiousdannii Oct 2 '20 at 2:26
  • $\begingroup$ Since you put what "we know" about the inner and outer bounds of the Oort Cloud at "from 2,000 to 200,000 au" and state that "We can reasonably compute the elliptical orbit of Halley's Comet why would you not just do that - or Google it - then compare the numbers? en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Halley%27s_Comet, for one, would have told you Halley's aphelion is about 35.082 AU and its perihelion about 0.586 AU… along with lots of other lovely Halley-facts. $\endgroup$ – Robbie Goodwin Oct 3 '20 at 21:25
13
$\begingroup$

No. Halley's Comet has an aphelion of 35 AU, which is far less than the believed boundaries of the Oort cloud.

Any object on an elliptical orbit with a perihelion of 0.6 AU and an aphelion of 2,000 AU has a semimajor axis of about 1,000 AU, and orbital period of about 31,600 years, much longer than Halley's Comet's current orbital period of 75-76 years. To get out to 200,000 AU and back on an elliptical orbit, you'd be looking at an orbital period of more than 31.6 million years.

As mentioned by @NilayGhosh and @planetmaker, 1P/Halley likely started as an Oort Clout object, was perturbed into becoming a long-period comet, and probably subsequently became the prototypical periodic comet through gravitational interactions with the solar system's gas giants at some point in the last couple hundred thousand years.

As such, though it is possible that Halley's comet may have been in an orbit whose aphelion went beyond the outer boundary of the Oort Cloud in its long-period-comet days, it certainly does not do so now.

Improve this answer
$\endgroup$
2
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ Halley is classified as a periodic or short-period comet. But Wikipedia says that it was once a long period comet, and it originate from Oort cloud but its orbits were perturbed by the gravity of the giant planets and directed into the inner Solar System $\endgroup$ – Nilay Ghosh Oct 1 '20 at 10:58
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ The Oort cloud generally is believed to be the reservoir for comets. Small perturbations there might scatter single objects into the inner solar system which then appear here as new comet - and subsequently might be subject to further changes of their orbit with Jupiter and other planets, reducing their semi major axis. $\endgroup$ – planetmaker Oct 1 '20 at 13:49
7
$\begingroup$

Without knowing anything specific about this comet, you can use Kepler's third law to get an idea whether this could be the case. It says that the cube of the semi-major axis is proportional to the square of the orbital period (with the same factor for all bodies orbiting the same central body): $$a^3 \propto T^2 $$

Comparing this to earth (which orbits the same star): $$ \frac{a^3_H}{T^2_H} = \frac{a^3_E}{T^2_E}$$ and thus (because $a_E = 1\,AU$ and $T_E = 1 \,\text{year}$, and using the 76 years from the question): $$ a_H = \Bigl(\frac{T_H}{T_E}\Bigr)^{\frac23} ·a_E = 76^{\frac23} ·a_E \approx 18 \,AU $$ This is the semi-major axis, and the aphelion can be at most double this distance (it is actually 35 AU, see the answer by notovny), but a lot less than the 2000 AU asked in the question.

Improve this answer
$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.