4
$\begingroup$

When a large asteroid impacts a rocky planet, the impact area becomes molten, looking red. However, when an asteroid or other large object impacts a gas giant, like Jupiter, the impact area turns dark brown. Why does this happen?

$\endgroup$
5
$\begingroup$

The initial impacts are brighter. The team that observed the shoemaker levy impacts described them as "fireballs" and the initial pictures showed spots glowing bright after impact, though I'm not sure how much those images used the infra-red range, so, grain of salt, because I think you're asking about the visible spectrum.

Jupiter's bands are essentially Hadley cells where the darker bands are the warmer rising atmosphere and the lighter band is the cooling, more icy falling atmosphere. The whiter bands across Jupiter's latitude lines, what you see is sunlight reflected off ammonia ice. (the blue color of Uranus and Neptune is methane ice). When gas giant planets get hotter, they tend to lose their pretty colors and become darker reddish or brown colors. They hydrogen and helium that dominate the atmosphere are mostly transparent. The color we see comes from ice-clouds and other molecules in the atmosphere.

Impacts on Jupiter, with the planet's high escape velocity, creates an enormous amount of heat for any impact big enough for us to see from Earth and perhaps obviously, heat removes ice.

A variety of molecules play a role in Jupiter's reddish/brown colors, I'm not sure which is dominant, but phosphine gas/phosphorus compounds, Sulphur and hydrocarbons all reflect or scatter darker colors. But the primary answer to your question is that the brown spots you see after impact are due to a lack of atmospheric ice in combination with sufficient mixing so that there's an abundance of colored molecules. It's not too different from Jupiter's large storms that create it's dark or red spots.

A more recent image of an impact taken by an amateur astronomer. The initial impact isn't dark. It's lighter due to the heat of impact reaching above visible temperatures with presumably some atmospheric covering.

enter image description here

If you use an infrared camera, you probably see the spots remain brighter for some time, even as they become darker in the visible spectrum.

$\endgroup$
2
$\begingroup$

What you are seeing is the top of a huge cloud of dust and smoke that forms in the Jovian atmosphere. It doesn't look "red" because it cools down quite rapidly.

In fact the same is true when an asteroid impacts Earth. There is a cloud of dust and smoke (that looks white because it is lit by the sun and is seen against the sky) If there is a crater formed there would be an explosion, but usually there isn't much melting and the fireball of the explosion cools down rapidly. The effect is similar to very powerful bomb. You get a flash, a great deal of heat, that can start fires and a blast the might create a crater. But you don't get much melting of rock. (For colossal impacts there might be significant melt, There might be secondary volcanism triggered by the impact but these are not the red molten rock you describe)

$\endgroup$
4
  • $\begingroup$ I might be confusing the red spots with major impacts. $\endgroup$ – fasterthanlight Nov 15 '20 at 13:14
  • $\begingroup$ @fasterthanlight The red spots and the famous giant red spot are large, long lasting storms between Hadley cells. It is, however, unknown how old the great red spot is and how it formed. It also appears to be shrinking, so it's possible that it may have come from a formation event or impact. It may not be a popular idea but it is at least theoretically possible. The planet's fast rotation / Coriolis effect in combination with lots of heat inside the planet and the spots fitting neatly between Hadley cells suggest weather not impacts, but there is a little room for debate. $\endgroup$ – userLTK Nov 15 '20 at 14:13
  • $\begingroup$ @userLTK I'm not talking about the Great Red Spot being an impact event. I'm confusing the red parts with large impacts (i.e. the Earth-Theia impact). $\endgroup$ – fasterthanlight Nov 15 '20 at 16:37
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ @fasterthanlight I guess I read "red spots" as meaning Jupiter's great red spot. Language can be a little confusing sometimes. $\endgroup$ – userLTK Nov 15 '20 at 16:39

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.