Assume that two Earth-like planets orbited the same star, with elliptic orbits. Eventually, something occurs that caused the two planets to collide.

What would be the outcome of such a catastrophe? I figure that both planets (and any life if it exists) would be destroyed, but exactly how?

Would both planets explode, combine together into a larger planet, or be able to rebound and either reestablish an orbit or be pulled into the sun?


1 Answer 1


To start with, such two orbits are extremely unlikely. First of all, any object orbiting a star and deviating strongly from a circular orbit has a high risk of crashing into something. As you notice, there are very few planets in our solar system, and all of them except Pluto have a very regular orbit. Planets which have intercrossing orbits would have crashed into each other and fallen apart on the planetesimal stage, much earlier than becoming a planet.

Then, if you suppose that such an event does occur, the consequences will depend on multiple factors. For one, the composition of the planets - if the two planets are terrestrial (rocky), one would expect them to fragmentate and lose a large amount of their mass. Their cores would maybe fuse into one planet, and the debris would form one or several satellites. The exact outcome would be dependent on their speed, their density, and the angle of their collisions. A similar (but not the same) scenario happened during the late stage of Earth formation, when an object close to Earth's size crashed into it to create the Moon. If the sizes are the same and the formation is complete, chances are that most of the matter would fly away and the planet that would be left would be tiny.

It would be a different story if the two planets are gaseous. They have almost no solid matter in them, so chances are that the planets will fuse whilst losing (proportionally) significantly less matter than terrestrial planets. Still, there would be losses.

Lastly, if a terrestrial and a gaseous planet meet, the outcome is quite easy to predict. Gas planets are much larger than rocky planets, so the rocky planet would simply be engulfed. It will maybe cause a disturbance on the surface of the gas giant.

To wrap it up let me just note that such a collision would almost definitely change the orbit of whatever is left, so that it would either get pushed into the sun or away from it, causing it to float eternally in outer space. Have a nice day.

  • $\begingroup$ But the earth didn't end up in the sun, or an long elliptical orbit. Its orbit is still almost circular. $\endgroup$
    – LDC3
    Commented Jan 9, 2015 at 1:57
  • $\begingroup$ That'd right , because a. I said it was unlikely, not impossible. b. Earth got hit at the protoplanetary stage, when it was much softer and smaller and there was much more matter around. It had time to be stabilized. $\endgroup$
    – L.R.
    Commented Jan 9, 2015 at 5:02
  • $\begingroup$ The bigger the masses, the less important the softness. Planets are hold by gravity and not by cohesion, so it doesn't matter much if they are hard or soft. Anyway, density plays its role. $\endgroup$
    – Pere
    Commented Jan 31, 2017 at 10:09

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .