176
votes
Accepted
Why is the discovery of merging neutron stars important?
Reasons why this is important:
It is the first simultaneous detection of a gravitational wave and electromagnetic signal, and the strongest GW signal yet in terms of signal to noise (Abbott et al. ...
- 140k
72
votes
Accepted
Can gravitational waves pass through a black hole?
No, gravitational waves cannot pass through a black hole.
A gravitational wave follows a path through spacetime called a null geodesic. This is the same path that would be followed by a light ray ...
- 1,629
51
votes
Accepted
Are binary neutron star mergers needed to explain the abundance of gold?
The creation of some very heavy neutron-rich elements, like gold and platinum, requires the rapid capture of neutrons. This will only occur in dense, explosive conditions where the density of free ...
- 140k
44
votes
Why is the discovery of merging neutron stars important?
Because its awesome (SMBC)
So this guy called Copernicus suggested that the Earth orbits the Sun (not the other way round) - What changes?
This guy Newton had a theory for how a mass responds to ...
- 112k
42
votes
Accepted
Is it suspicious that gravitational waves propagate at the speed of light?
It is very suspicious! It points to the fact that the speed of light isn't just some random speed that light happens to travel at, but is a fundamental property of the universe.
In fact, any massless ...
- 112k
37
votes
Accepted
What did LIGO Actually See? (Gravitational waves discovery)
The actual image isn't much. I was able to find it from Science, and this is all it is:
It's just a ripple, seen at slightly different times from two different observatories. The shift fits perfectly ...
- 3,000
32
votes
What observations can be expected on LIGO if any when Betelgeuse goes supernova?
Potentially, a short (less than a second) burst of gravitational waves (GWs) would be detected. Much depends on asymmetries in the core collapse, since a spherically symmetric collapse would not ...
- 140k
30
votes
What did LIGO Actually See? (Gravitational waves discovery)
First of all, I think your question belies a misunderstanding of the nature of the LIGO observatories. The nature of the detectors is that they act like a microphone, as opposed to a camera. What ...
- 522
29
votes
Accepted
Is there an upper limit on the mass of black hole mergers we can detect?
It is quite likely there is an astrophysical upper limit to the mass of a black hole that can be produced during the core collapse of a massive star, caused by the pair instability supernova ...
- 140k
28
votes
Accepted
Quantum Mechanics after the detection of Gravitational Waves
No more than the observation of light waves disproves quantum mechanics.
Light has properties of both a particle and a wave. At low energies, the particle nature of light is hard to detect: radio ...
- 112k
26
votes
Accepted
Why are there not yet any instruments dedicated to registering time dilation caused by passing gravitational waves?
General relativity predicts that there are only two possible polarizations of gravitational waves, the so-called "tensor" polarizations $+$ and $\times$. It turns out you can show that the ...
- 35.8k
25
votes
Accepted
Why can't supermassive black holes merge? (or can they?)
The main problem is angular momentum. In order for two gravitationally bound objects to merge (whether black holes, supermassive black holes, planets, stars, etc.), they must shed enough angular ...
- 2,613
25
votes
Accepted
Why does the sensitivity to GWs drops off inversely proportional to the distance?
EDIT I'm leaving the original, highly upvoted answer below, but I've had a fundamental rethink about this, prompted by questions from Keith McClary and a helpful clarification from a Physics SE ...
- 140k
21
votes
Quantum Mechanics after the detection of Gravitational Waves
The impact of this measurement on the status of quantum gravitation is exactly zero.
The proper statement of the incompatibility of general relativity and quantum mechanics is that the quantum field ...
- 311
21
votes
Accepted
What if the two Black Holes spiraling around each other are evaporating via their Hawking radiation?
Gravitational waves are efficiently emitted by massive black holes orbiting each other - the power emitted increases with mass. Hawking radiation on the other hand is a process that increases with ...
- 140k
20
votes
Accepted
"Who saw" the binary neutron star merger first? What was the sequence of events? (GRB/GW170817)
The initial Fermi trigger can be found here, and the following sequence of alerts that were sent out by the LIGO Scientific Collaboration/Virgo Collaboration (LVC) and various electromagnetic ...
- 591
19
votes
Quantum Mechanics after the detection of Gravitational Waves
Another question, how can we identify the ripple's origin (let's say that if it's the result from the big bang or another big event)?
(I'm just answering this part of the question, as James has ...
- 2,427
18
votes
Accepted
Black Hole Collision & Gravitational Waves
Part of the answer is easy. The strain measured in that event was about $0.25\times 10^{-21}$. That is an object $1m$ long would be squeezed by $0.25\times 10^{-21} m$ in one direction and stretched ...
- 10.1k
17
votes
Sound of a black hole merger
What would be heard is vibrations set up by the gravitational wave in the atmosphere, although presumably they would also directly stimulate the parts of the ear too.
The amplitude of gravitational ...
- 12.6k
16
votes
Accepted
How far away are the events that caused the gravitational waves that have been detected?
Yes, it is possible to calculate (within an error range) the distance of observed gravitational wave events. It is known that a variety of parameters will affect how the amplitude and frequency of ...
- 3,415
16
votes
Accepted
How is the Hubble constant determined from gravitational waves?
If you measure the gravitational waveform from an inspiralling binary, you can at any point measure the amplitude, instantaneous frequency and the rate of change of frequency. The last two give you ...
- 140k
16
votes
Are there any gaps in the range of gravitational wave frequencies we can detect?
Are there any wavelengths in between the ranges of these different detectors that we wouldn't be able to detect?
Yes! There is the millihertz band, which will be detectable by the space-based ...
- 4,439
15
votes
Accepted
Why do Earth and moon move apart but binary black holes move closer?
Here is how the tides move the moon away from the Earth:
The moon orbits the earth, and there is a difference in gravitational force between the the side of the Earth nearest the moon, and the side ...
- 112k
15
votes
What did LIGO Actually See? (Gravitational waves discovery)
LIGO didn't "see" anything. It monitors the relative lengths of the paths taken by two laser beams in vacuum pipes about 4km long (although the laser path consists of about 75 trips up and down the ...
- 140k
15
votes
Why did astronomers believe most or all stellar black holes had masses no greater than 15 solar masses?
The so-called 'mass gaps' for black holes, according to theoretical models, are between 2-5 solar masses and 50 to 150 solar masses. (Actually, I have read that there is no good theoretical reason for ...
- 4,439
15
votes
Accepted
Can gravitational waves transfer energy or momentum to baryonic matter
The classic thought experiment showing that GW carries real energy is the "sticky bead argument" due to Feynman. Two beads on a rigid rod will be moved relative to each other and the rod by ...
- 12.6k
14
votes
Accepted
Why can there be several seconds of lag between a binary neutron star merger and the emission of gamma rays from the same area?
The paper (section 5.1) discusses three possibilities in the context of a relativistic fireball model, where some of the kinetic energy in relativistic jets of material emerging from the explosion is ...
- 140k
13
votes
Why can we detect gravitational waves?
The short answer is that waves that are "in the apparatus" are indeed stretched. However the "fresh waves" being produced by the laser are not. So long as the "new" waves spend much less time in the ...
- 140k
13
votes
Accepted
How far should the source be, for the gravitation waves to be visible on Earth?
The waves pass by at the speed of light. So you you would'nt see ripples, they would pass too fast, and remember the waves would be passing through you too. The wavelength was (relativly) long about ...
- 112k
Only top scored, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible