Skip to main content
Notice removed Draw attention by CommunityBot
Bounty Ended with no winning answer by CommunityBot
Notice added Draw attention by uhoh
Bounty Started worth 400 reputation by uhoh
Notice removed Draw attention by CommunityBot
Bounty Ended with no winning answer by CommunityBot
Notice added Draw attention by uhoh
Bounty Started worth 200 reputation by uhoh
Notice removed Draw attention by CommunityBot
Bounty Ended with no winning answer by CommunityBot
edited tags
Link
uhoh
  • 30.7k
  • 9
  • 98
  • 313
Notice added Draw attention by uhoh
Bounty Started worth 100 reputation by uhoh
added 18 characters in body; edited title
Source Link
uhoh
  • 30.7k
  • 9
  • 98
  • 313

Why does titanium oxide around Betelgeuse produce this particular sawtooth-shaped absorption spectrum?

Betelgeuse Just Isn’t That Cool: Effective Temperature Alone Cannot Explain the Recent Dimming of Betelgeuse suggests that the recent dimming might be caused by increased optical absorption by dust around the star, based on a spectral analysis.

Question: The images below show absorption features assigned to titanium oxide (TiO) around Betelgeuse. Why are these features saw-tooth shaped? When I think of absorption edges the transmitted light drops when crossing from lower to higher energy photons, but here the measured light increases from lower to higher energy.

note 1: A quick check shows that these shapes are typical, so it's really just a matter of me not understanding why these features have the particular shapes that they do.

note 2: There is some discussion of Betelgeuse's titanium lines in the second half of Scott Manley's Astronomers Think They Know Why Betelgeuse Got Dimmer

Fig. 1.— Optical spectrophotometry of Betelgeuse from 2020 (black) and 2004 (red)

Fig. 1.— Optical spectrophotometry of Betelgeuse from 2020 (black) and 2004 (red).

Fig. 2.— Normalized and continuum-flattened spectra of Betelgeuse from 2020 and 2004

Fig. 2.— Normalized and continuum-flattened spectra of Betelgeuse from 2020 (black) and 2004 (red dashed), illustrating the relative depths of the Teff-sensitive TiO bands (labeled) in both spectra.

Why does titanium oxide produce this particular sawtooth-shaped absorption spectrum?

Betelgeuse Just Isn’t That Cool: Effective Temperature Alone Cannot Explain the Recent Dimming of Betelgeuse suggests that the recent dimming might be caused by increased optical absorption by dust around the star, based on a spectral analysis.

Question: The images below show absorption features assigned to titanium oxide (TiO). Why are these features saw-tooth shaped? When I think of absorption edges the transmitted light drops when crossing from lower to higher energy photons, but here the measured light increases from lower to higher energy.

note 1: A quick check shows that these shapes are typical, so it's really just a matter of me not understanding why these features have the particular shapes that they do.

note 2: There is some discussion of Betelgeuse's titanium lines in the second half of Scott Manley's Astronomers Think They Know Why Betelgeuse Got Dimmer

Fig. 1.— Optical spectrophotometry of Betelgeuse from 2020 (black) and 2004 (red)

Fig. 1.— Optical spectrophotometry of Betelgeuse from 2020 (black) and 2004 (red).

Fig. 2.— Normalized and continuum-flattened spectra of Betelgeuse from 2020 and 2004

Fig. 2.— Normalized and continuum-flattened spectra of Betelgeuse from 2020 (black) and 2004 (red dashed), illustrating the relative depths of the Teff-sensitive TiO bands (labeled) in both spectra.

Why does titanium oxide around Betelgeuse produce this particular sawtooth-shaped absorption spectrum?

Betelgeuse Just Isn’t That Cool: Effective Temperature Alone Cannot Explain the Recent Dimming of Betelgeuse suggests that the recent dimming might be caused by increased optical absorption by dust around the star, based on a spectral analysis.

Question: The images below show absorption features assigned to titanium oxide (TiO) around Betelgeuse. Why are these features saw-tooth shaped? When I think of absorption edges the transmitted light drops when crossing from lower to higher energy photons, but here the measured light increases from lower to higher energy.

note 1: A quick check shows that these shapes are typical, so it's really just a matter of me not understanding why these features have the particular shapes that they do.

note 2: There is some discussion of Betelgeuse's titanium lines in the second half of Scott Manley's Astronomers Think They Know Why Betelgeuse Got Dimmer

Fig. 1.— Optical spectrophotometry of Betelgeuse from 2020 (black) and 2004 (red)

Fig. 1.— Optical spectrophotometry of Betelgeuse from 2020 (black) and 2004 (red).

Fig. 2.— Normalized and continuum-flattened spectra of Betelgeuse from 2020 and 2004

Fig. 2.— Normalized and continuum-flattened spectra of Betelgeuse from 2020 (black) and 2004 (red dashed), illustrating the relative depths of the Teff-sensitive TiO bands (labeled) in both spectra.

Tweeted twitter.com/StackAstronomy/status/1248536346362286080
added 196 characters in body
Source Link
uhoh
  • 30.7k
  • 9
  • 98
  • 313

Betelgeuse Just Isn’t That Cool: Effective Temperature Alone Cannot Explain the Recent Dimming of Betelgeuse suggests that the recent dimming might be caused by increased optical absorption by dust around the star, based on a spectral analysis.

Question: The images below show absorption features assigned to titanium oxide (TiO). Why are these features saw-tooth shaped? When I think of absorption edges the transmitted light drops when crossing from lower to higher energy photons, but here the measured light increases from lower to higher energy.

note 1: A quick check shows that these shapes are typical, so it's really just a matter of me not understanding why these features have the particular shapes that they do.

note 2: There is some discussion of Betelgeuse's titanium lines in the second half of Scott Manley's Astronomers Think They Know Why Betelgeuse Got Dimmer

Fig. 1.— Optical spectrophotometry of Betelgeuse from 2020 (black) and 2004 (red)

Fig. 1.— Optical spectrophotometry of Betelgeuse from 2020 (black) and 2004 (red).

Fig. 2.— Normalized and continuum-flattened spectra of Betelgeuse from 2020 and 2004

Fig. 2.— Normalized and continuum-flattened spectra of Betelgeuse from 2020 (black) and 2004 (red dashed), illustrating the relative depths of the Teff-sensitive TiO bands (labeled) in both spectra.

Betelgeuse Just Isn’t That Cool: Effective Temperature Alone Cannot Explain the Recent Dimming of Betelgeuse suggests that the recent dimming might be caused by increased optical absorption by dust around the star, based on a spectral analysis.

Question: The images below show absorption features assigned to titanium oxide (TiO). Why are these features saw-tooth shaped? When I think of absorption edges the transmitted light drops when crossing from lower to higher energy photons, but here the measured light increases from lower to higher energy.

note: A quick check shows that these shapes are typical, so it's really just a matter of me not understanding why these features have the particular shapes that they do.

Fig. 1.— Optical spectrophotometry of Betelgeuse from 2020 (black) and 2004 (red)

Fig. 1.— Optical spectrophotometry of Betelgeuse from 2020 (black) and 2004 (red).

Fig. 2.— Normalized and continuum-flattened spectra of Betelgeuse from 2020 and 2004

Fig. 2.— Normalized and continuum-flattened spectra of Betelgeuse from 2020 (black) and 2004 (red dashed), illustrating the relative depths of the Teff-sensitive TiO bands (labeled) in both spectra.

Betelgeuse Just Isn’t That Cool: Effective Temperature Alone Cannot Explain the Recent Dimming of Betelgeuse suggests that the recent dimming might be caused by increased optical absorption by dust around the star, based on a spectral analysis.

Question: The images below show absorption features assigned to titanium oxide (TiO). Why are these features saw-tooth shaped? When I think of absorption edges the transmitted light drops when crossing from lower to higher energy photons, but here the measured light increases from lower to higher energy.

note 1: A quick check shows that these shapes are typical, so it's really just a matter of me not understanding why these features have the particular shapes that they do.

note 2: There is some discussion of Betelgeuse's titanium lines in the second half of Scott Manley's Astronomers Think They Know Why Betelgeuse Got Dimmer

Fig. 1.— Optical spectrophotometry of Betelgeuse from 2020 (black) and 2004 (red)

Fig. 1.— Optical spectrophotometry of Betelgeuse from 2020 (black) and 2004 (red).

Fig. 2.— Normalized and continuum-flattened spectra of Betelgeuse from 2020 and 2004

Fig. 2.— Normalized and continuum-flattened spectra of Betelgeuse from 2020 (black) and 2004 (red dashed), illustrating the relative depths of the Teff-sensitive TiO bands (labeled) in both spectra.

added 219 characters in body
Source Link
uhoh
  • 30.7k
  • 9
  • 98
  • 313
Loading
added 14 characters in body; edited title
Source Link
uhoh
  • 30.7k
  • 9
  • 98
  • 313
Loading
Source Link
uhoh
  • 30.7k
  • 9
  • 98
  • 313
Loading