Will the Heat Death scenario ever occur or just the Big Freeze?

According to the Wikipedia page regarding the ultimate fate of the universe, heat death is a different scenario than the big freeze.

It states that in the big freeze, temperature will asymptotically approach absolute zero. However, the following section about heat death states that heat death may only occur if temperature reaches an eventual temperature minimum.

If temperature never truly reaches absolute zero (the temperature minimum), can heat death even occur in the first place?

The Wikipedia article is somewhat confused on this point (at least one of the references does not support the sentence it is supposed to support).

The classic concept of the heat death of the universe was that eventually it will run out of free energy and there will hence be no possibility of any work. A more modern view of heat death is an approach to maximum entropy where the system will be in equilibrium. This does not rule out random fluctuations bringing it away from equilibrium, but they are so rare it does not matter.

Note that it is entirely possible to have a heat death at any temperature.

The big freeze would happen if expansion of the universe led to temperatures decreasing towards absolute zero. However, if there is accelerating expansion this generates a constant finite temperature horizon radiation, about $$10^{-29}$$ K. This means that the big freeze will never happen.

Had there not been horizon radiation it would in principle have been possible to avoid heat death by storing some background heat in a perfectly reflective box, waiting until the universe become colder, and use it to perform work. This can be repeated indefinitely. (Not really: the timescales quickly become long enough that random fluctuations destroy your device, but that it a separate issue).

• Ah, thank you. That makes a lot more sense. Commented Apr 11, 2020 at 12:16
• Additionally, if expansion never ceases, wouldn't that indicate a big rip scenario being more likely? Commented Apr 11, 2020 at 12:21
• @SamPritchard - No, indefinite expansion does not imply a big rip or give any evidence in favour of it. Big rips require $w<-1$, a statement about the nature of dark energy, while one can easily have indefinite expansion with or without dark energy. In fact, measures of the expansion rate constrain big rip scenarios really weakly: arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/0309109 Commented Apr 11, 2020 at 14:13

Due to the universe not only expanding but gaining speed, it's pretty well accepted (for now at least) that galaxies will be sitting alone, or maybe with other gravitationally bound neighbor galaxies, as the rest of the universe goes dark all around. Eventually our home galaxy would burn out it's last star. Thats the big freeze, and not happening for a while... The end stages at least. Its seems like heat death is a variation to the big freeze, except expansion somehow stops for heat death? and im not sure what the universal temperature is thought to plato at, but after all thermodynamic process' end, the universe' energy will be lost to the void and entropy will reach its maximum as universal equilibrium is reached (uniform temperature and lack of activity) but tthe time it would take for the last black hole to evaporate is so long it's hard to comprehend, 10^100 or a googol years, if im not mistaken. heat death and the big freeze seem like different ways of explaining the same event, the former being on a longer time scale, but both seeming headed for the same fate. and wiki and google agree most of the time, but a few articles off a google search said the opposite. I think maybe you read some info from contradicting sources is all, if there is a difference in these two, its that expansion stops for heat death, allowing a marginally warmer universe than one with infinite expansion. there is no reason to think thats going to happen with our current understanding of dark energy.

• Expansion of the universe doesn't look like it will stop ever. I'm just curious whether or not heat death can happen, as asymptotically indicates the temperature will never truly reach absolute zero, just closer and closer. Wikipedia states Heat Death may only occur if a temperature minimum is reached first though. Would this mean Heat Death can never occur? Commented Apr 11, 2020 at 12:12
• en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heat_death_of_the_universe. Think that has the answer for you. There is no target temperature needed, thermodynamic energy to exhaust, and entropy can reach its maximum state with thermodynamic equilibrium everywhere. Commented Apr 11, 2020 at 13:29